Never Won a Major Prize

Native Son

by Richard Wright

Summary

Bigger Thomas, a poor young Black man on Chicago's South Side, takes a chauffeur's job for the wealthy Dalton family and, on his first night driving their daughter Mary home drunk, accidentally smothers her while trying to keep her quiet in her own bedroom for fear of being discovered there. Panicked, Bigger burns her body in the family furnace and tries to pin the death on Mary's communist boyfriend Jan, extracting ransom money from the terrified Daltons before the plot unravels. He then murders his own girlfriend Bessie Mears to stop her from talking, a killing far more calculated than Mary's death ever was. Once caught, Bigger stands trial with a communist lawyer, Boris Max, arguing in his defense that Bigger's violence is the direct, foreseeable product of a society that has spent his whole life treating him as something less than a person; the argument does not save him, and the novel ends with Bigger convicted and sentenced to death, waiting in his cell with something close to clarity about who he has become and why.

Wright refuses to make Bigger sympathetic in any conventional sense, writing his fear and rage without softening either one, a deliberate rejection of the more consoling protest fiction Wright felt Black writers had been pressured to produce before him. It reads with real, propulsive dread once the plot is set in motion, Bigger's own terror driving the pace as much as the crimes themselves, and the trial section slows the novel down deliberately to let Max's argument land in full.

The Book of the Month Club's selection of Native Son sold two hundred and fifty thousand hardcover copies in its first three weeks alone, making Wright, almost overnight, the wealthiest Black writer in America to that point. The club had also demanded the removal of a scene involving masturbation before it would carry the book, a cut the Library of America finally restored in a complete 1991 edition, half a century after the compromise was made.

Historical Context & Significance

Harper and Brothers published Native Son on March 1, 1940, and Orson Welles directed a stage adaptation that opened on Broadway barely a year later, in March 1941, with Canada Lee as Bigger. No prize marked it. The 1941 Pulitzer board wanted Hemingway's For Whom the Bell Tolls over its jury's preferred candidates, then gave nothing after Columbia's president objected to the book, so the year Native Son was eligible ended with no winner at all; the book's real institutional recognition was the Book of the Month Club, which made it the first main selection by a Black American author.

Reception split sharply along lines that have shaped the book's discussion ever since. Irving Howe later wrote that American culture changed the day Native Son appeared, while James Baldwin's 1949 essay Everybody's Protest Novel argued the book's anger came at the cost of real human complexity, a rebuke Wright never fully accepted. The novel remains on the American Library Association's list of frequently challenged books, and it has been filmed three times, in 1951, 1986 and 2019, the 2019 version leaving Bessie's murder out of the story altogether.