Caldecott Medal Winner

Always Room for One More

by Nonny Hogrogian

Summary

Sorche Nic Leodhas retells a Scottish folk song she said she first heard from her own grandfather, about Lachlan MacLachlan, called Lachie, a warmhearted Highlander who already shares a small cottage with his wife and ten children. When travelers caught out by bad weather come knocking, Lachie never turns anyone away, inviting in one more guest and then another, each one squeezing into a house that is already full past any reasonable limit. The cottage keeps filling until the walls finally give way under the weight of so many grateful strangers, and the whole small house collapses around its overcrowded but happy occupants. Rather than blame Lachie for his open door, the neighbors who benefited from his kindness over the years pitch in together and build the family a bigger house in its place, one large enough that Lachie can keep right on saying yes to every traveler who comes asking for a bed.

Nonny Hogrogian, who trained in woodcut under printmakers Antonio Frasconi and Hodaka Yoshida and used it for her first published book in 1960, gives the Highland cottage and its ever growing crowd of guests a grainy, textured look rather than a smooth, painted one, the rooms visibly more crowded with travelers on every page until the walls themselves seem to strain against the frame. It reads well aloud to children around four to eight, its repeating pattern of knock, welcome and squeeze making the growing crowd easy to follow even before the walls finally give way, and the eventual collapse tends to land as a satisfying release rather than a disaster once a young listener has watched the house fill up for several pages running.

Historical Context & Significance

Always Room for One More, published by Henry Holt in 1965, won the 1966 Caldecott Medal, the first of two Hogrogian would win; she took the medal again in 1972 for One Fine Day, making her one of only a handful of illustrators to win it twice.

Sorche Nic Leodhas was the pen name of the Scottish American writer Leclaire Alger, who built several books out of family stories and songs passed down from her grandfather. That year's Honor books were Roger Duvoisin's Hide and Seek Fog, Marie Hall Ets's Just Me and Evaline Ness's Tom Tit Tot. Hogrogian, whose parents had fled the Armenian genocide, later became known, in the New York Times's own description, for "bringing multiculturalism to children's literature" by drawing on her own heritage in her retellings, a pattern already visible here in her choice to illustrate someone else's inherited Scottish tale with the same care she later brought to Armenian folklore of her own.