Russia Leaves the War: Soviet-American Relations, 1917–1920
by George F. Kennan
Summary
George F. Kennan opens his history of early Soviet American relations with Russia's exit from the First World War, following the confused, often improvised diplomacy between Washington and the new Bolshevik government through the Brest Litovsk negotiations that finally took Russia out of the fighting in March 1918. Kennan traces the mutual suspicion, crossed signals, and missed opportunities on both sides that hardened an already difficult relationship into the deeper antagonism that would define much of the twentieth century, drawing on American diplomatic records alongside the published Russian documents available to Western historians at the time.
Kennan wrote as a career Foreign Service officer and lifelong specialist in Russian affairs rather than as an academic historian by training, and that background shows throughout: the book reads with the practical, close grained understanding of diplomatic maneuvering of someone who had actually conducted this kind of negotiation himself, rather than reconstructed it from the outside. He is unusually willing to credit both sides with genuine confusion rather than settled bad faith, showing American officials working from incomplete and often contradictory information about a revolutionary government whose own intentions toward the wider world were still very much unformed. It is the opening volume of a longer study of Soviet American relations in this period, continued in a companion volume, The Decision to Intervene, and it suits a reader interested in the diplomatic roots of the Cold War, told by one of the American officials most responsible for shaping the policy, containment, that grew directly out of the mistrust this book describes.
Historical Context & Significance
Russia Leaves the War won the 1957 Pulitzer Prize for History for its 1956 publication, along with the National Book Award. Kennan had already become one of the most consequential American diplomats of the century by the time the book appeared, having authored the anonymous 1947 Foreign Affairs article that laid out the containment policy guiding American strategy toward the Soviet Union through the Cold War, and having briefly served as ambassador to the Soviet Union in 1952.
After leaving the Foreign Service, Kennan joined the faculty of the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton in 1956, the same year this book appeared, and spent the rest of his long career writing history and commentary from that post. Russia Leaves the War remains valued for combining a working diplomat's firsthand feel for negotiation with genuine archival research into a period few other historians of the time could access with equal fluency.