Hugo Award for Best Novel Winner

To Say Nothing of the Dog

by Connie Willis

Summary

Ned Henry is an Oxford historian in 2057, and he has time lag: too many jumps to the past in too few weeks, running errands for Lady Schrapnell, an American millionaire who is rebuilding Coventry Cathedral exactly as it stood before the German bombing of November 1940. The one object still missing is the bishop's bird stump, a Victorian flower vase of such comprehensive ugliness that nobody can describe it and everybody remembers it.

To let Ned rest, his supervisor sends him to 1888, where his instructions are garbled and he understands almost nothing. There he joins a boating party on the Thames, meets a don, a bulldog and a cat, and discovers that another historian has already brought something back from the past that should have stayed there, which may have altered the outcome of the Second World War.

The novel is an affectionate rewrite of Jerome K. Jerome's Three Men in a Boat, whose actual characters row past at one point, crossed with a country house comedy, a seance, a hopeless romance and a genuinely clever plot about causality that pays off every apparently pointless digression.

It is the sunniest thing Willis wrote and reads like a holiday, though at five hundred pages it takes its time and the farce of people misunderstanding each other is sustained for a very long stretch.

Read Doomsday Book first if you want, but it is not required. Best for readers who want Wodehouse with a time machine and a real puzzle underneath.

Historical Context & Significance

To Say Nothing of the Dog won the 1999 Hugo Award for Best Novel and the Locus Award for Best Science Fiction Novel.

Its full title is To Say Nothing of the Dog: or, How We Found the Bishop's Bird Stump at Last, which is a direct salute to Jerome K. Jerome's Three Men in a Boat, To Say Nothing of the Dog of 1889.

Connie Willis has won eleven Hugo Awards and seven Nebula Awards for individual works, more major awards than anyone else in the field, and was named a Science Fiction Writers of America Grand Master in 2011.

It belongs to her Oxford time travel sequence, which swings between registers: this is a comedy, Doomsday Book is about the Black Death, and Blackout and All Clear return to the Blitz. Coventry Cathedral was really destroyed on 14 November 1940 and its ruins stand beside the modern replacement.