Collected Poems 1917–1952
by Archibald MacLeish
Summary
Collected Poems 1917 to 1952 spans thirty five years of Archibald MacLeish's writing, from his earliest work through the modernist experiments that made his reputation to the more publicly engaged verse of his later career, and reading it in order means watching a poet's whole relationship to his art change over decades. MacLeish's most famous single poem, Ars Poetica, distills his early, Eliot and Pound influenced modernism into its own closing claim, that a poem should not mean but be, arguing for poetry as pure aesthetic object rather than as message or statement. You, Andrew Marvell extends that same technical mastery, a poem built on the felt approach of nightfall traveling westward across the globe, into one of the most admired single poems of his career.
The collection also carries MacLeish's later turn away from pure aestheticism toward direct engagement with public and political concerns, a shift that tracked his own life outside poetry: he served as Librarian of Congress from 1939 to 1944, reforming the institution and securing greater funding for it, then as Assistant Secretary of State for Public Affairs from 1944 to 1945, where he helped shape the founding documents of UNESCO. That movement from the private, formal concerns of Ars Poetica toward poems engaged with public life gives the collection its real shape, less a single consistent voice than the visible record of a poet's convictions changing under the pressure of history.
Reading Collected Poems 1917 to 1952 suits anyone curious how a committed modernist aesthetic can loosen, under the weight of depression, war and public office, into poetry willing to argue directly about the world rather than simply to exist apart from it.
Historical Context & Significance
The Pulitzer board gave Archibald MacLeish the 1953 Pulitzer Prize for Poetry for Collected Poems 1917 to 1952, his second Pulitzer for poetry after Conquistador won in 1933. MacLeish would go on to win a third Pulitzer, for drama, in 1959, for his play J.B., which also won that year's Tony Award for Best Play, making him one of only a handful of writers to win Pulitzers in more than one category.
By the time of this poetry prize, MacLeish had already served as Librarian of Congress and as Assistant Secretary of State, giving the award to a public figure as much as to a working poet. From 1949 to 1962 he held the Boylston Professorship of Rhetoric and Oratory at Harvard, a position that let him continue writing and teaching poetry for another decade after this collection's recognition, well past the public offices that had occupied much of his middle career.